BaxterBoo.com
Autoship Save 15% on your 1st Autoship learn more

Plush & Mice Toys

1 - 99 of 157 Items
  • KONG Holiday Wrangler Cactus Cat Toy - Dots
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    Starting at:
    $7.97
  • KONG Holiday Pull-A-Partz Present Cat Toy - Argyle
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    Starting at:
    $7.97
  • HugSmart Kitten Party Cat Toy - Vineyard Delight
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    Starting at:
    $5.97
  • Huxley & Kent Hanukkah Plush Cat Toy - Meow-zel Tov Dreidel
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    Starting at:
    $4.99
  • Huxley & Kent Holiday Food Plush Cat Toy - Meh' Nog
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    Starting at:
    $4.99
  • P.L.A.Y. Feline Frenzy Forest Friends Cat Toys - Mama & Chip 2 Toy Set
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    Starting at:
    $9.97
  • P.L.A.Y. Feline Frenzy Forest Friends Cat Toys - Foxsy and Hopsy 2 Toy Set
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    Starting at:
    $9.97
  • P.L.A.Y. Feline Frenzy Forest Friends Cat Toys - Bandit Buddies 2 Toy Set
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    Starting at:
    $9.97
  • Kittybelles Celebration Bundle Plush Cat Toy - First Lick Heart & Be Mine Coffee
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    Starting at:
    $7.99
  • Worthy Dog Kicker Cat Toy - Kaleidoscope Bear
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    Starting at:
    $6.00
  • Worthy Dog Kicker Cat Toy - Chili Pepper
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    Starting at:
    $9.00
  • Worthy Dog Ball Cat Toy - Chick
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    Starting at:
    $6.00
  • Worthy Dog Kicker Cat Toy - Fishy
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    Starting at:
    $6.00
  • Worthy Dog Kicker Cat Toy - Gone Fishin
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    Starting at:
    $9.00
  • Worthy Dog Kicker Cat Toy - Al the Gator
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    Starting at:
    $6.00
  • On Sale!
    HugSmart Holiday Feline Meow Buddies Cat Toy – Lump of Coal
    Save 40%
    Starting at:
    $4.78  $7.97
  • On Sale!
    HugSmart Spooky Cats Meow Buddies Cat Toy – Witch's Brew
    Save 40%
    Starting at:
    $4.78  $7.97
  • HugSmart Spooky Cats Meow Buddies Cat Toy – Ghost Kitty
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    Starting at:
    $7.97
  • On Sale!
    HugSmart Spooky Cats Meow Buddies Cat Toy – Candy Basket
    Save 40%
    Starting at:
    $4.78  $7.97
  • HugSmart Kitten Party Cat Toy – Pizza & Soda
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    Starting at:
    $6.97
  • On Sale!
    HugSmart Kitten Party Cat Toy – Hot Dog & Mustard
    Save 40%
    Starting at:
    $4.18  $6.97
  • On Sale!
    HugSmart Kitten Party Cat Toy – Cheese & Wine
    Save 40%
    Starting at:
    $4.18  $6.97
  • Pearhead Holiday Cat Toy Set - Nutcracker Set
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    Starting at:
    $5.99
  • On Sale!
    SnugArooz Holiday Fruit Plush Cat Toy - Kitty Berry Christmas
    Save 40%
    Starting at:
    $2.99  $4.99
  • Kittybelles Booze Plush Cat Toy - Cats Blue Ribbon
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    Starting at:
    $4.99
  • HuggleKat Wee Feller Squirrelie Cat Toy
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    Starting at:
    $10.99
  • HuggleKat Wee Chippie and His Acorn Cat Toy - 2 pack
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    Starting at:
    $11.99
  • HuggleKat Sardinies Cat Toy - 3 pack
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    Starting at:
    $10.99
  • On Sale!
    Clearance
    HuggleKat Ma-Cat-a-Roonies Cat Toy with Catnip - 3 pack
    Save 33%
    Starting at:
    $8.00  $11.99
  • HuggleKat Jellie Fish Cat Toy with Catnip - 3 pack
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    Starting at:
    $11.99
  • HuggleKat Fur Ballies Cat Toy with Catnip - 3 pack
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    Starting at:
    $10.99
  • HuggleKat FlufferFleece Balls Cat Toy with Catnip - 3 pack
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    Starting at:
    $10.99
  • HuggleKat Dust Bunnies Cat Toy with Catnip - 3 pack
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    Starting at:
    $11.99
  • HuggleKat Chickies Cat Toy with Catnip - 3 pack
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    Starting at:
    $11.99
  • HuggleKat Bindies Cat Toy - 2 Pack Butterflies
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    Starting at:
    $10.99
  • Kittybelles Celebration Bundle Plush Cat Toy - Me-Wow Cupcake & Candle
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    Starting at:
    $7.99
  • Kittybelles Celebration Bundle Plush Cat Toy - Firecracker & All Star Pawdka
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    Starting at:
    $7.99
  • Kittybelles Food Plush Cat Toy - Snoreo Cookies
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    Starting at:
    $4.99
  • Kittybelles Food Plush Cat Toy - Snif
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    Starting at:
    $4.99
  • Kittybelles Food Plush Cat Toy - Meowmellow Stuff
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    Starting at:
    $4.99
  • On Sale!
    HugSmart Kitten Party Cat Toy – Strawberry Cake
    Save 40%
    Starting at:
    $2.98  $4.97
  • On Sale!
    HugSmart Kitten Party Cat Toy – Carrot Cake
    Save 40%
    Starting at:
    $2.98  $4.97
  • HuggleKat Wee Squooshie Mice Cat Toy with Catnip - 2 pack
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    Starting at:
    $11.99
  • Kittybelles Plush Booze Cat Toy - Tickled Pink Chompagne
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    Starting at:
    $4.99
  • Kittybelles Kitty Klaw Plush Booze Cat Toy - Clawberry
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    Starting at:
    $4.99
  • HugSmart Crazy Catcher Meow Buddies Cat Toy – Helicopter
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    Starting at:
    $3.97
  • HugSmart Crazy Catcher Meow Buddies Cat Toy – Bus
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    Starting at:
    $3.97
  • On Sale!
    HugSmart Kitten Party Cat Toy – Popcorn
    Save 40%
    Starting at:
    $2.38  $3.97
  • Pearhead Fall Cat Toy Set - It's Meowple Season
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    Starting at:
    $4.99
  • Pearhead Holiday Cat Toy Set - Naughty or Nice Fish
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    Starting at:
    $4.99
  • On Sale!
    Pearhead Halloween Cat Toy Set - Pawloween
    Save 40%
    Starting at:
    $2.99  $4.99
  • On Sale!
    FuzzYard Halloween Cat Toy - Tina Tarantula
    Save 40%
    Starting at:
    $5.39  $8.99
  • On Sale!
    SnugArooz Plush Cat Toy - Kitty Llamaste
    Save 40%
    Starting at:
    $2.99  $4.99
  • On Sale!
    SnugArooz Plush Cat Toy - Kitty Avocato
    Save 40%
    Starting at:
    $2.99  $4.99
  • Clearance
    KONG Holiday Tropics Cat Toy - Santa
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    Starting at:
    $7.97
  • Clearance
    KONG Holiday Puzzlements Hideaway Cat Toy - Gingerbread
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    Starting at:
    $7.97
  • Kittybelles Plush Booze Cat Toy - Prrride Champagne
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    Starting at:
    $4.99
  • Kittybelles Strings Plush Cat Toy - Party Hats
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    Starting at:
    $4.99
  • Kittybelles Booze Plush Cat Toy - Kitty Loco Tequila
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    Starting at:
    $4.99
  • Kittybelles Plush Fish Cat Toy - Rainbow Guppy
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    Starting at:
    $4.99
  • Kittybelles Food Plush Cat Toy - Kitty Pop
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    Starting at:
    $4.99
  • On Sale!
    HugSmart Kitten Party Cat Toy – Beer
    Save 40%
    Starting at:
    $2.38  $3.97
  • Mad Cat Beach Babe Cat Toy - 2 Pack
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    Starting at:
    $10.48
  • Mad Cat Narwhal with Silverine Stick Cat Toy
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    Starting at:
    $6.56
  • KONG Crackles Flutterz Cat Toy
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    Starting at:
    $7.97
  • KONG Tropics Hula Cat Toy
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    Starting at:
    $7.97
  • P.L.A.Y. Feline Frenzy Kicker Cat Toy - Tuna Baguette
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    Starting at:
    $10.57
  • P.L.A.Y. Feline Frenzy Kicker Cat Toy - Shrimp Purrito
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    Starting at:
    $10.97
  • KONG Puzzlements Hideaway Cat Toy
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    Starting at:
    $7.97
  • Kittybelles Kitty Klaw Plush Booze Cat Toy - Licks & Lime
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    Starting at:
    $4.99
  • P.L.A.Y. Feline Frenzy Cat Toys - Kitty Kreme Donuts 3 Toy Set
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    Starting at:
    $10.57
  • P.L.A.Y. Feline Frenzy Cat Toys - Twice as Mice 2 Toy Set
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    Starting at:
    $9.97
  • P.L.A.Y. Feline Frenzy Cat Toys - Hooti-ful Owls 2 Toy Set
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    Starting at:
    $9.97
  • KONG Crackles Gulpz Cat Toy
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    Starting at:
    $6.97
    5.0 (1)
  • KONG Flingaroo Caterpillar Cat Toy
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    Starting at:
    $6.97
  • KONG Pull-A-Partz Cheezy Cat Toy
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    Starting at:
    $8.97
  • KONG Pull-A-Partz Purrito Cat Toy
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    Starting at:
    $6.97
  • KONG Pull-A-Partz Yarnz Cat Toy
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    Starting at:
    $5.97
  • Cat is Good Food Junkeez Catnip Cat Toy - Strawberry & Pineapple
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    Starting at:
    $5.97
  • Cat is Good Food Junkeez Catnip Cat Toy - Avocado & Banana
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    Starting at:
    $5.97
  • Chomper Kylie's Brights Knit Mouse with Feathers Cat Toy - 2-Pack
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    Starting at:
    $5.97
  • Chomper Kylie's Brights Mice and Balls Cat Toys - 8-Pack
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    Starting at:
    $9.97
  • Pet Park Blvd Mouse Cat Toys - 12 Pack
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    Starting at:
    $11.97
  • Savvy Tabby Knit Mice, Fur Mice & Ball Cat Toys - 12 Pack
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    Starting at:
    $10.97
  • Chomper Kylie's Brights Feather Rattler Mice Cat Toy - 4 Pack
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    Starting at:
    $6.97
    5.0 (1)
  • KONG Better Buzz Bananas Cat Toy
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    Starting at:
    $6.97
  • P.L.A.Y. Feline Frenzy Cat Toys - Sassy Sushi 3 Toy Set
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    Starting at:
    $10.57
  • On Sale!
    P.L.A.Y. Feline Frenzy Cat Toys - Farm to Tabby 3 Toy Set
    Save 40%
    Starting at:
    $5.98  $9.97
  • P.L.A.Y. Feline Frenzy Cat Toys - Wiggly Wormies 2 Toy Set
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    Starting at:
    $9.97
  • P.L.A.Y. Feline Frenzy Cat Toys - Tutti Fur-utti 2 Toy Set
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    Starting at:
    $9.97
    5.0 (1)
  • P.L.A.Y. Feline Frenzy Cat Toys - Catch a Mowse 2 Toy Set
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    Starting at:
    $9.97
  • P.L.A.Y. Feline Frenzy Cat Toys - Purrfect Picnic 2 Toy Set
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    Starting at:
    $9.97
  • Kittybelles Funfetti Cake Sweet Plush Cat Toy
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    Starting at:
    $4.99
  • Kittybelles Kitty Cake Plush Booze Cat Toy
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    Starting at:
    $4.99
  • Kittybelles Purring Angel Rosé Plush Booze Cat Toy
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    Starting at:
    $4.99
  • Kittybelles Whisker's Whisky Plush Booze Cat Toy
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    Starting at:
    $4.99
  • Clearance
    Meowijuana Get Smoked Refillable Fish Cat Toy
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    Starting at:
    $8.99
  • Clearance
    Meowijuana Get Blitzed Refillable Reindeer Cat Toy
    Earn 10% in rewards!
    Starting at:
    $8.99
    5.0 (1)
  • On Sale!
    Clearance
    HuggleKats Woodland Creatures Cat Toys
    Save 42%
    Starting at:
    $15.00  $25.99
 

About Our Plush & Mice Toys

Cats love to cuddle almost as much as they love to chase. Give them a plush cat toy and they’ll have their own little buddy that they can enjoy during both naptime and playtime. Keep your cat busy with a variety of mice toys designed to engage their hunting instincts, giving them plenty of practice to prepare for chasing real mice invading your home. KONG Wubba cat toys combine catnip-infused plush materials with crinkling tails and a rattling mouse-shaped body that will appeal directly to your cat’s desire to stalk and capture their prey. Available in all sorts of fun themes from realistic-looking fish to yummy-looking food, Kittybelles plush cat toys are non-toxic and filled with organic catnip to keep your cat chewing and pouncing. Cook up some fun with handmade P.L.A.Y. Feline Frenzy Cat Toys that are as eco-friendly as they are feline friendly. Find these exiting options along with other great catnip toys to round out your cat’s toy collection when you stop at BaxterBoo, your ultimate one-stop shop for cat toys, cat treats and other quality cat supplies!

Related Categories: Cat Scratchers, Cat Scratching Posts, Catnip & Pet Grass, Balls & Chasers, Teasers & Wands, Interactive & Electronic Cat Toys, Cat Toy Variety Packs

Sign Up For Our Newsletter!